Maybe Walter didn't get hit by the train. He died trying to overcome his fears. Get Edith Finch Here: https://www.epicgames.com/store/en-US/product/what-remains-of-edith-finch/home (free until Jan 24 2019)What did the creators of Edith . Wow, really interesting theory! I like it, but I don't think it explains everything. [30], The game won the award for "Best Story" in PC Gamer's 2017 Game of the Year Awards,[31] and was nominated for "Game of the Year". It begins to look almost like the bark of a tree; something that has an order to it, but its too chaotic for us to be able to follow. The wind picked up and he managed to do it but as he swung round he was flung from the seat towards the ocean and into the rocks below. Lewis' room is similarly normal, typical for a man who hit his twenties in the early 2010s - he has a PC with a double monitor and a gaming mouse, here and there you can see some CD-Rs lying around. His mother, Kay, is distracted by the phone after she empties the tub of water and Gregory manages to fill it up again. He takes a sledgehammer and smashes through the wall, stating that he can't keep living the same day over and over anymore. The drowning sequence set to "The Waltz of the Flowers" from The Nutcracker by Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, and Lewis', a mini-adventure game taking place in Lewis' mind while at the same time decapitating fish at a cannery that was inspired by "The Coronation of Mr. Thomas Shap" from The Book of Wonder. It was first announced in an on-stage trailer at the 2014 PlayStation Experience, as a title to be published by Santa Monica Studio,[5] with a subsequent trailer released prior to E3 2015. Was crushed by tent equipment after refusing to go indoors in a storm. He believed in the curse as much as Edie so Edith speaks about it in her commentary as she explores the grounds and cemetery surrounding the Finch house. Their debut effort was the BAFTA-award-winning The Unfinished Swan. The player character takes a ferry to Orcas Island, Washington carrying the journal of Edith Finch. The most likely explanation is that some of what she ate (berries, toothpaste, gerbil food) poisoned her and she began to hallucinate these strange happenings, wrote about it in her journal, and died from the effects. The ending isnt as clear as some of the stories throughout the game so it is open to interpretation. She says, maybe we believed so much in the family curse we made it real, which is how Dawn felt about it the day they left. You can only say that Walter "definitely" got hit by a train the same way you can say Molly turned into an actual sea monster. Train tracks below the Finch house Some items she understandably felt pride in and wanted to preserve, such as a wooden model of the house, likely put together by her husband Sven as an actual model for the actual house, or books written by her father Odin. The one that caused the water to dissappear. The propaganda posters in his room, as well as the fact that Sam was a teen in the Sixties tell us of a child who closely followed the developments of the Cold War and who, judging by the pictures he took during his time away, perhaps went to fight in Vietnam. Despite many of the rooms having been meticulously sealed, some memories spilt out, perhaps in an attempt to impress potential visitors - such as a picture of Barbara on a film set in the hallway and several of Sam's photos throughout the house. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, Battle at the Illuminati Headquarters (Earth-838), Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. She wears casual clothing, but her regular set clothing is that of a . (Could contain spoilers), What really happened to Edith **SPOILER**. The player repeats this action several times, and each time the screen goes black and another can of peaches sits in front of the player, and each time, the date on the calendar progresses. Either scenario seems equally as likely based on the information the game presents us with, because of some impressively restrained and careful writing, and that type of care is ubiquitous throughout the entirety of What Remains of Edith Finch. Walter died the way it was shown I think. Calvin has always wanted to go over the top of the branch to which the swing down by the sea was connected but he had always been too scared to do so. Marital status In an unspecified time in the future, Christopher places flowers on his mother's grave. Through the house she encounter a series of memorials to her deceased relatives. Maybe he was blinded by the sun (remember he was living underground for 30 years) and fell off the cliff. In home school, she learnt the story of her family, but never actually learnt about the occupants of her own house. $4.99. Looking at Walter's grave it has him just looking out to sea and I believe he either fell by accident following the destroyed railway, or threw himself into the ocean. [32] It was also nominated for "Best Xbox One Game" in Destructoid's Game of the Year Awards 2017;[33] for "Best Adventure Game" and "Best Story" in IGN's Best of 2017 Awards;[34][35] and for "Best Moment or Sequence" (Cannery Sequence) in Giant Bomb's 2017 Game of the Year Awards.[36]. The sternly worded house rules next to the list of chores tell us of Sam's fear of losing his children as well as his dedication to discipline. [Image Source: What Remains of Edith Finch Wiki]Some of the death stories are more cut and dry, like Calvin falling off the swing and over the cliff, or Walter being hit by the train, or Sam being pushed to his death by the half-dead deer. They're family and Edith was home-schooled, it's much easier to know their handwriting. Even without Edith telling you, the few light sources throughout, the paraphernalia and the additional console tell you that Lewis' biggest passions were smoking, gaming and generally being left alone. Sanjay is the only known deceased Finch Family member without the last name "Finch". However, Ian Dallas says that, Milton is The King, not the protagonist, in The Unfinished Swan, and that he considers it to be canon in the Giant Sparrow universe. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. The second time playing, you know each characters role in the story and you are able to link them to what happens to each member of the family and it makes the ending even more poignant. At 10 years old, Molly dies after ingesting fluoridated toothpaste and holly berries; at 16, Barbara is murdered during a home invasion or implied domestic dispute; at 11, Calvin falls to his death after swinging off the edge of a cliff; at 49, Edie's husband Sven dies during a construction accident at the house; and, at 53, after having spent 30 years living as a recluse in a bunker beneath the house and traumatized at witnessing Barbara's death, Walter is hit by a train after stepping outside for the first time since. Walter gets up and goes to one end of the bunker, opening a hatch on the floor. Why did they discontinue it? Drowned in the bathtub after he had been left alone and the water turned back on. Likely this is with Edie's coercion. He told a different story to his son and left behind something hopeful instead of a curse. ", "2018 SXSW Gaming Awards Winners Revealed", "Breath of the Wild & Horizon Zero Dawn lead GDC 2018 Choice Awards nominees! Odin Finch - While attempting to sail his house across the ocean he ended up sinking. In her small room, Barbara is surrounded by film memorabilia with her likeness on it. Reexploring the house, she uncovers her family's mysterious past and learns about the series of deaths that eventually caused the complete collapse of her family structure. You have to take every story with a grain of salt, some easier to decipher, others less so. - 1982: Dawn murders Gus. Please enable JavaScript to see comments. As a 17-year-old, Edith writes that she is the last surviving member of her family. Edie's mural of Walter for his memorial shrine. * Could he have gotten scared and fallen off the cliff? 52 (at time of death)64 (by April 25th, 2017) The stories that Edith is relaying to us are often outlandish and obviously embellished, and come from a host of unreliable narrators, from a ravenous eleven-year-old girl, to a puzzled psychiatrist, to a deeply traumatized great-grandmother. The tracks curve around the side of the cliff to your right as you face the part where they're broken. Inspired by the story of Harry R. Truman, a man who had refused to leave his home prior to the eruption of Mount St. Helens, the team had envisioned a scenario that Edie would have also refused to leave her family home despite the threat of a nearby forest fire sometime in the 1980s. However, this idea came too late in the development without enough time to follow up on it. It is a beautiful story that becomes even more touching with extra playthroughs. Initially I was satisfied that yes he'd been hit by a train and the tracks had since crumbled into the sea, but now thinking about it I believe the train was the monster he was so scared of, amplified in his mind after his encounter with Barbara's 'killer', but that the train stopped running due to the earthquake. Edith was six when he died but she never even knew that he was living under her house all those years. However, Edith wants to ensure that her child hears about the fate of their family so she writes down everything in her journal once she reaches what used to be her room. If Walter died in 1968, who writes his letter in 2005? The books on monsters on her shelf, the scorpion in a jar and the Pacific Ocean Depth Chart on the other hand tell a story of her fascination with some more unsettling creatures, which she will eventually turn into the night she dies. [Image Source: Moby Games]When we consider the likely answers to these mysterious deaths, all signs point to great-grandma Edie being the secret villain of the story. Most items you find represent a more benign form of materialism: in instrumental materialism, items are repositories for meaning for their former owners or those who knew them. Gregory Finch - Drowned in a bathtub due to parental neglect. Mollys story, the first you play in What Remains of Edith Finch, is both one of the strangest and hardest to decipher in the game. :). Dallas had considered asking Carpenter to narrate this section, but at the time, the video game voice actor strike was ongoing, making this impossible, but Carpenter did agree to license the use of the Halloween theme for this sequence. I think he walked off the cliff at the exact spot where you later saw the tracks had eroded off. He mentions 'the monster beneath roaring', and the day he didn't hear the rumbling, he left his bunker with the belief that said 'monster' had grown tired of waiting for him. Initially, they considered a scenario similar to The Canterbury Tales but set in a modern-day high school,[1] but soon recognized that placing these deaths in context of a cursed family would work better, forming an anthology work like The Twilight Zone, while borrowing concepts from the novel One Hundred Years of Solitude, which similarly involved the overlapping stories of various family members. She particularly loves interactive storytelling and cuddling with her cats. I think the game has been updated since you played it last, I just finished it and Walter was definitely hit by a train, there's no doubt about it. Stardew Valley 7. However, Edith wants to ensure that her child hears about the fate of their family so she writes down everything in her journal once she reaches what used to be her room. He thought that staying underground was the only way to protect himself, even if that meant cutting himself off from his family. The concept of What Remains of Edith Finch grew out from trying to create something sublime, as described by Dallas, "an interactive experience that evokes what it feels like to have a moment of finding something beautiful, yet overwhelming". Milton Finch (The King) - Indicated to have died by the quote, "none of this will last for long". Date of birth Thank you for sharing. The performances are stellar, especially that of Valerie Rose Lohman as the titular role, the art is beautiful, and the game revolutionized narrative design on multiple occasions. She returns to her room where she is writing about what has happened to her while the monster waits for her under her bed. Walter had been underground for a long time so he didn't know the railway had collapsed. [27][28] EGMNow ranked the game at #25 in their list of the 25 Best Games of 2017,[29] while Polygon ranked it 13th on their list of the 50 best games of 2017. A triumph in the genre. Lewis story is the most heartbreaking and beautifully told individual tale in What Remains of Edith Finch. These included the infant Gregory, who drowns while in the bath while his mother is distracted. Someone should make a game about: bookshops, Feature| They leave with Edie still at the house and they never see her again. I'd type out the supporting evidence but don't have time. Yeah but remember, there's a long gap between Edith's time and Walter's time. The player plays as Walter, who is seated in a chair in front of a calendar, a clock, and a can of peaches. What happened to Edith Finch house? Walter Finch. Could have been the mole man Edie gave the interview on. Gus story is told through a poem written by Dawn, who is Ediths mother, and Gus sister. There is so much wonderful and surprising detail, both ostentatious and subtle, in the rooms that make up its impossible, wonderful house of dreams and death.